Saxophone Comparisons

The Shootout

I have chosen to compare five saxophones, three vintage and two modern. The vintage saxophones are my own two tenors, a 1930s Conn 10M (Naked Lady) and a 1950s “The” Martin, along with a 1954 Selmer MKVI which I borrowed. The two modern tenors are a Yanagisawa 901 and one of the new generation of inexpensive Chinese saxophones, a Walstein – a phosphor bronze instrument with a design based around a Yanagisawa 992.

As with most saxophone comparisons, the testing was not subject to rigorous scientific processes, no blindfolds, no panel of objective listeners (just my wife). I went into this with as open a mind as possible, the results surprised me somewhat so hopefully you can get something useful from it, but please always bear in mind how subjective this is. I don’t believe in a best sound, just a favourite sound.

Summary

So which was the best instrument? Well, there wasn’t one. For some interesting discussion see this post on Sax On The Web.

Each of the vintage saxophones had more “character” – which admittedly can be a double-edged sword. They each absolutely excelled at one style, but were let down somewhere else. Among the vintage instruments I was surprised how good the MKVI was (I used to use one, but ditched it in favour of the Conn 10M many years ago – but this just shows how much individual instruments can differ – there are very good and very bad MKVIs, this was a good one). The MKVI had the smoothest sound over the whole range and it sounded better when playing modern jazz & bebop. The Martin however did not compare too well in the jazz department, but beat all the horns hands down when it came to Rock & Roll. Sadly the MKVI wimped out slightly for me when trying to make it rock, but maybe that is just me – some of my favourite rock and roll saxophonists are MKVI players. The Conn had much of the MKVIs pizzaz but with slightly better intonation and was almost as good for bebop, but it really held its own on a lush ballad or hard swinging jump jive.

The two modern instruments were both very smooth and even, but did not quite have the character, although if anything the Yanagisawa seemed to be the horn of choice for smooth jazz and 70s funk. Of all the instruments though, the Walstein is probably the most versatile, in that it was almost as good as the others in each of their speciality, and did not do badly at anything.

I purposely paid very little attention to intonation. All saxophones have their tuning quirks, and most players get used to, and compensate for, a particular instrument’s tuning foibles. When you try a new instrument, often you are subconsciously compensating for the old one so it can be very difficult to fairly evaluate the intonation without spending days or weeks. However I felt that none of these instruments seemed to have any major tuning issues that would not be resolved with just getting used to them.

Click here for answers

  Jazz Rock Ballads Smooth Versatility
1 Conn 10M **** **** ***** *** ****
2 The Martin *** ***** **** *** ***
3 Selmer MKVI ***** *** **** **** ***
4 Walstein **** **** **** **** *****
5 Yanagisawa *** **** *** ***** ***

Sponsored Links:

 

Subscribe To Our (very occasional) Newsletter
Subscribe to our email newsletter today to receive updates on the latest news, tutorials and special offers!
No Thanks
Thanks for signing up. You must confirm your email address before we can send you. Please check your email and follow the instructions.
We respect your privacy. Your information is safe and will never be shared.
Our
Don't miss out. Subscribe today.
×
×
Frequently Asked Questions
I did not receive the email with with my download link

Please check your spam folder.

NB: Purchased downloads are also available to download directly from your customer account area.

I am having a problem downloading to iPad or iPhone

This is a common issue and affects all downloads, not just our products. In order to download anything to iPad etc. you will need an app that can handle .zip .pdf and .mp3 downloads.

See this article and/or this app

It may be easier to download to your desktop and then transfer to your tablet.

Download expired, reached its limit
  • The download may actually have  expired. Download links are valid only for a certain number of days and have a limit on number of downloads - please contact us with your order number and date of purchase to reset it. (Ideally reply to your order confirmation email)
  • Download manager/accelerator  software or browser plugin is interfering with the download. If so try disabling it.
  • The files did actually  download, but very quickly and you did not realise. Please do a search of your download destination directory before contacting us.
Do you sell outside the UK?

Yes, we sell internationally. Your currency will be automatically converted at the current exchange rate.

Saxophone Instruction DVD region compatibility

This is a PAL all region DVD so will not require you to reset your DVD player/computer region.

However as it is PAL format it may not be compatible with some older U.S. TV sets which are NTSC only, please check if your TV and/or DVD player is compatible with PAL format.

If not, it should still work on any computer with DVD drive (anywhere in the world). Please note we have only tested the DVD by playing on DVD systems or playing on computers with standard DVD hardware and software. We cannot guarantee that files extracted (ripped) from the DVD will play successfully. Sharing of copied DVDs or ripped files is illegal.

How much will postage cost?

After adding an item or several items to your cart, click on the Calculate Shipping button and choose your location from the dropdown menu. This will give you the postage options available to your country.

When will I get my stuff?

Products in stock

We usually post within 3 days of receiving an order. We are unable to give exact delivery times, but generally packages to Europe can take 2 - 7 days, outside Europe 4 - 14 days. Under exceptional circumstances (weather, strikes, customs delays) it can take longer.

Out of stock (backorders) or special orders

Out of stock books and DVDs are generally restocked within a week. Out of stock or special order mouthpieces can take between 6 and 10 weeks for manufacturing.

From time to time we have a holiday, in which case items will take longer, look out for any noticesd at the top of the page re:holidays.

How do I find out the price in dollars, yen, euros, dirhams etc?

The checkout pages shows prices in GBP (£). Your bank, credit card company or Paypal take care of the actual conversion, so you can pay with your normal account in your own currency. We don't publish actual rates in different currencies as this is constantly changing so we advise you check with a live currency conversion site such as xe.com

Thanks for signing up. You must confirm your email address before we can send you. Please check your email and follow the instructions.
×
×